I just finished Naomi Novik’s Spinning Silver in basically one sitting, which I haven’t done for a mid-size fantasy novel in a while! There are a lot of reasons I found it personally gratifying to read, but I think it deserves to be praised for the role one of the protagonists’ identity as a Jewish woman plays in the story.
The ways her identity and culture is woven into her psyche is so thoughtfully done. As with any fantasy novel worth its salt, Miryem’s ‘outsider’ identity –her Jewishness– comes in handy when she has to solve problems in the mysterious magical world. But it doesn’t feel gimmicky. She remembers her traditions and beliefs and values in the same ways I do as someone who holds their culture within them while functioning in a world that doesn’t know it. It surfaces as a personal touchstone about how to proceed in the unknown, and that’s beautiful.
More explicitly, she comes from a family of moneylenders and becomes one herself. Her arc starts out at her building her identity out of a reaction to being a minority who is discriminated against and owning it. It’s an age-old theme, but I’ve never seen it done with Jewish identity in this kind of fantasy story. (And I’ve read a jillion fantasy novels set in old-timey Europe with young female protagonists.)
Touring around Europe (and in history classes) I heard over and over how Jewish people were shoved into ghettos and marginalized while being relied upon for services Christians couldn’t provide. I am frankly floored I’ve never seen a protagonist like Miryem before. That’s why I couldn’t be more pleased that she is written by Novik, because world-building and sense of history are among her greatest strengths, which serves not just Miryem’s characterization, but the other POV characters who interact with her and her family, and as a result, their unfair treatment in the world.
Read the book because Irina is a goddamn badass and my QUEEN. And because the UST between the romantic pairings is so finely tuned you’ll be mad where one of the plotlines ends (in a good way). Read it for great female protagonists in general. Read it for the clever story and deeply satisfying mythos. And also read it ‘cause awesome Jewish representation!